The 1986 NHL Supplemental Draft took place on September 15, 1986.
| # | Player | Nationality | NHL Team | College (League) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Chris Olson (G) |  United States |
Boston Bruins | University of Denver (WCHA) |
| 2. | Jeff Capello (LW) | Template:CAN | Buffalo Sabres | University of Vermont (Hockey East) |
| 3. | John Cullen (C) | Template:CAN | Buffalo Sabres | Boston University (Hockey East) |
| 4. | Steve MacSwain (RW) | United States |
Calgary Flames | University of Minnesota (WCHA) |
| 5. | Dave Randall (D) | Template:CAN | Chicago Blackhawks | Northern Michigan University (CCHA) |
| 6. | Rob Doyle (D) | Template:CAN | Detroit Red Wings | Colorado College (WCHA) |
| 7. | Peter Heinze (D) | United States |
Edmonton Oilers | University of Massachusetts Lowell (Hockey East) |
| 8. | Joe Tracy (RW) | United States |
Hartford Whalers | Ohio State University (CCHA) |
| 9. | Bob Kudelski (C) | United States |
Los Angeles Kings | Yale University (ECAC) |
| 10. | Grant Paranica (RW) | Template:CAN | Los Angeles Kings | University of North Dakota (WCHA) |
| 11. | Brian McKee (D) | Template:CAN | Minnesota North Stars | Bowling Green State University (CCHA) |
| 12. | Randy Exelby (G) | Template:CAN | Montreal Canadiens | Lake Superior State University (CCHA) |
| 13. | Glen Engevik (RW) | Template:CAN | New Jersey Devils | University of Denver (WCHA) |
| 14. | Tim Barakett (F) | United States |
New Jersey Devils | Harvard University (ECAC) |
| 15. | Gary Kruzich (G) | United States |
New York Islanders | Bowling Green State University (CCHA) |
| 16. | Gary Emmons (C) | Template:CAN | New York Rangers | Northern Michigan University (CCHA) |
| 17. | Jeff Lamb (F) | United States |
Pittsburgh Penguins | University of Denver (WCHA) |
| 18. | Randy Taylor (D) | Template:CAN | Pittsburgh Penguins | Harvard University (ECAC) |
| 19. | Mike Natyshak (F) | Template:CAN | Quebec Nordiques | Bowling Green State University (CCHA) |
| 20. | Marty Raus (D) | United States |
St. Louis Blues | Northeastern University (Hockey East) |
| 21. | Art Fitzgerald (G) | United States |
Toronto Maple Leafs | Trinity College (NESCAC) |
| 22. | David Gourlie (D) | Template:CAN | Vancouver Canucks | University of Denver (WCHA) |
| 23. | Steve Cousins (D) | Template:CAN | Washington Capitals | University of Alberta (CIAU) |
| 24. | Chris Levasseur (F) | United States |
Winnipeg Jets | University of Alaska Anchorage (WCHA) |
| 25. | Ian Kidd (D) | United States |
Detroit Red Wings | University of North Dakota (WCHA) |
